Solution: The Internet
So, I'm anti textbook. We don't have to get into the specificities of being green because I'm okay with supporting the tree harvest industry. But the problem really is that our society is moving away from reading from a book. And this is where the traditionalist (and maybe my wife who's the best reading specialist around) will say "You have to be able to read from a book." Well, I agree, and I'm not against reading the printed word.
So what's my problem? Like I briefly mentioned, we don't communicate and we don't get our entertainment from typed/printed material anymore - so what happens? Evolution my friends. As we continue to move more on line with communication, we are beginning to lose the need for something to be printed - it takes too long to travel (and frankly, printers have yet to catch up to the "it just works" side of the computer age). Making a choice between writing a letter and typing a message into Facebook becomes a decision that works exactly like how my high school biology teacher explained "Natural Selection". It's just a better choice - like a giraffe picking a mate by the longest neck, that one's going to get the most food at the top of the tree, so maybe your kids will too. And the simple genetics of the giraffe gradually lengthens the neck over time.
In the communication model, there is send-receive-feedback and back again. So what's the point of writing using envelopes and stamps waiting for the mail, waiting for the mail, waiting for the mail, receive... repeat (and this includes interoffice mail)... you get the picture.
So keeping that in mind, how up to date is your science textbook? How up to date is that info by the time the latest addition gets to you? How much new science is understood every day? How many of you know the model for evolution (monkey to man) is an outdated evolutional model? Yeah, look it up (and by "look it up" - an outdated phrase referring to text books - I mean google it. Or, I don't care, if you want to go to the library and search the Dewey Decimal system for the latest info be my guest. I'll bet you won't do it -first of all- and then you'll never know and how will that shape your thought process as a person? ). I mean, forget the debate to teach the theory evolution as theory - we are even teaching the wrong theory! Because we are using textbooks we haven't elevated our argument yet. This slows our educational process down, it slows our evolution of thought/acceptance down.
How much has forensic science shaped our thoughts on history? Look up (meaning google) the gunfight at OK Corral. You'll be hard pressed to find anything closer to the facts than the accounts that use the latest crime scene investigations. And how has outdated info shaped our thoughts on cowboys - even the word cowboys? How about law enforcement?
And let's not get started on the cutthroat industry of textbook publishing... this means you too super intendants and principals. I mean, *sarcasm* I wonder why the publishing company won't send a representative to you? Oh, why would they want to fly you to Hawaii to meet them when their offices are in Minnesota?"
Take a moment to look at what it costs -just in terms of money- every year per student to buy a textbook. Take a moment then to consider the damage and loss, the amount of updating and how outdated information is. Think about the loss of skills when a student turns a text book in at the end of the year, what does that tell them about History? It told me I was done with History, that the dates and mostly events no longer apply to my life. I won't need the information ever again and if I did how would I look it up anyway? I'd probably not bother. And what was that quote about history and "doomed to repeat"? You get my idea.
Solution Time: Google Search.
"Oh! We can't let our kids search Google! You can't control what they might find!"
-BESIDES- Wouldn't you and your parents rather the students run across offensive materials in a learning environment where things can be pointed out and corrected immediately? Rather them finding it by themselves, alone in a dark room? And you know they will find it, it may take them being in a college dorm room one day but it will pop up and will they know how to handle it? The stuff that is out there is traumatizing the first time you see it no matter what your age is or how mature you might be.
You can filter what they might find! And still give them the freedom to personalize and thus internalize process more effectively the most up to date information.
Why, Google Advanced Search, silly. If you are a science teacher, you can find all the science sites you could ever approve of out there on the interwebs, load them into what is called a Google Custom Search Engine (you can even customize the look and feel of your search engine) and turn your students loose. Having them write an essay using internet sources is much more "trackable". This also eliminates them running into sites where students trade papers on certain topics. It also gives you a way to use the custom search engine to type their best phrases in, and search with quotes to see how badly they may or may not have plagiarized!
Terminate the text book! It's a crutch for the traditionalist living in fear. And you may be a traditionalist, but I've just given you a workout routine that will let you burn the crutch! So get to it. Right now, before you think about it, RIGHT CLICK on http://www.google.com/cse/ and select "Open in New Tab" (or "Window" if you prefer) When you're done reading here you'll have the page to look at so you won't forget or think it's going to be some huge ordeal > Click on "Create Custom Search Engine" on the right > Fill in the blanks > Get searching. (you may need a Google Account and if you don't have one you should get one now. All that is required is an email address from any email provider.)
IDEAS that came to mind while typing this:
If they are able to type, let them take notes on google docs so they can access it at home and/or print their individual notes. Maybe instead of an essay you have them all find different sources and share to the group.You could have them copy and paste notes and pictures and even videos into a google slideshow and then they would be presenting organized thoughts (which is close to the writing process) and using visuals to emphasize that organization (a skill that is above the writing process). It provides a quick solution to stretching an assignment out over a long period of time because you're waiting on them to write / type.
OTHER IDEAS? Please post them!
FEEDBACK? Please comment!
DID YOU TRY THIS OUT? Let me know what happened!